Stanley kubricks a clockwork orange is an ideological mess, a paranoid rightwing fantasy masquerading as an orwellian warning. It refuses to be erased, however, and for this the film version of the book made by. In a world unlike our own, roguish rascal, alex malcome mcdowell, and his gang of droogs, just keep on getting into trouble, all of the bleeding time. Apr 21, 2018 if youve seen the movie, you can most probably remember the spinetingling, infamous opening shot of a clockwork orange. A clockwork orange is a 1971 dystopian crime film adapted, produced, and directed by stanley kubrick, based on anthony burgesss 1962 novel a clockwork orange. Stanley kubricks adaptation of anthony burgess 1962 novel is a disturbing masterpiece. Differences between a clockwork orange book vs movie page 1.
Free will vs determinism in a clockwork orange, by anthony. The korova milk bar was described to be more like a real bar where alex and the gang. How a clockwork orange author anthony burgess soured on. The novel was adapted into a classic movie by stanley kubrick. Whats the difference between a clockwork orange the book and a clockwork orange the movie. The teenage protagonist, alex, narrates his violent exploits and his experiences with state authorities intent on reforming him. We will discuss the booklet and the movie a clockwork orange. There are a lot of hard words in it and alex and his three friends speak a dialect, called nadsat. Stanley kubrick dissects the nature of violence in this darkly ironic, nearfuture satire, adapted from anthony burgesss novel, complete with nadsat slang. Today we compare the book and film of a clockwork orange. Focus in images, with the team of cinefix, on the striking differences between the novel written by anthony burgess and the movie version of a clockwork orange which was directed by the legendary stanley kubrick. The videoinstallation a clockwork orange by dennis neuschaeferrube shows the movie a clockwork orange reduced to its colour.
A film that depicted trauma, and in sharing it traumatised the audience. The way alexs eyes just look right into yours on that extreme closeup. It is set in a dismal dystopian england and presents a firstperson account of a juvenile delinquent who undergoes statesponsored psychological rehabilitation for his aberrant behavior. A clockwork orange is a dystopian nightmarish fantasy of a nearfuture england, where teenage hooligans neglect the somewhat standing laws of society, and take control of the streets after dark. Did stanley kubrick steal the spotlight or does the original still sing. In the first part of the book, alex is a teenager who enjoys. After that glenn vh show us some differences between the book and the movie.
If youve seen the movie, you can most probably remember the spinetingling, infamous opening shot of a clockwork orange. This movie is quite unlike the shining, which was a screenplay heavy rewritten by kubrick to document his personal trials. A clockwork orange comparison of the book and film. A clockwork orange anthony burgess a clockwork orange is a dystopian novel by english writer anthony burgess, published in 1962. The novels main character, fifteen year old alex, and his three droogs, take place in allnight acts of random. The title of the authors book is a clockwork orange, and states that rules can not be enforced on man, or he becomes a clockwork orange, a foreshadowing of alexs conditioning. Alex buys the girls ice cream and food prior to raping them. It employs disturbing, violent images to comment on psychiatry, juvenile delinquency, youth gangs, and other social, political, and economic subjects in a dystopian nearfuture britain alex malcolm mcdowell, the central character, is. It is a dystopian novel, set in a near future english society, where extreme youth violence runs rampant. I personally think the book was more chilling and it seemed like alexs life had fallen apart after the treatments. A clockwork orange quizzes about important details and events in every section of the book.
Burgess believed that the freedom to choose is the big human attribute, this belief provides the central argument of a clockwork orange, where alex must follow the ludovico treatment. It employs disturbing, violent images to comment on psychiatry, juvenile delinquency, youth gangs, and other social, political, and economic subjects in a dystopian nearfuture britain. In this tribute from 2014, trainspotting author irvine welsh explains why burgesss a clockwork orange is a classic. He was portrayed by malcolm mcdowell in the 1971 film adaptation, who also played caligula in the 1979 film caligula, colonel f. Hi im at the part in the book where alex has just reasserted his control over his droogs towards the st.
Burgess knew that the current slang would become obsolete in a few years, so invented his own set based on russian. A clockwork orange 1971 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. First of all, there is no indication throughout the movie and i presume the book that alex is interested in any genuine change. Also pretty unethical, which was one of the major themes of the book read the book, its way better than the movie, and thats saying something and movie a clockwork orange.
Youre uncomfortable and the movie hasnt even begun yet. Strangelove in 1963 and 2001, a space odyssey in 1968, stanley kubrick makes a third film of science fiction in 1971 with a clockwork orange, adaptation of the eponymous novel by anthony burgess. Set in a near future english society featuring a subculture of extreme youth violence, the teenage protagonist, alex, narrates his violent exploits and his experiences with state authorities intent on reforming him. How does the film adaptation of a clockwork orange differ. Free will vs determinism in a clockwork orange, by anthony burgess 1208 words 5 pages in anthony burgess 1962 dystopian novella, a clockwork orange, teenage gangs and hoodlums run rampid in a futuristic society, inflicting mayhem and brutality among its totalitarian governed state. While imprisoned alex learns of the death of his former droog georgie during a botched burglary. A clockwork orange was a great movie and also it was really creepy to watch. I have read the book a clock work orange and i have liked it a lot. Alex, the protagonist of a clockwork orange, is not a character that would.
A clockwork orange read book or watch film first showing 1. A clockwork orange is almost a foreignlanguage work. Anthony burgess dismissal of the stanley kubrick adaptation of his novel a clockwork orange is one for the ages. The film adaptation, directed by stanley kubrick, is based on the american edition of the book. Differences between a clockwork orange book vs movie page 2. The way anthony burgess writes, with his strange madeup language nadsat, a russianinfluenced. We are going to discuss the book and the movie a clockwork orange. It was weird because i have found the book in my high school library. Burgess penned a clockwork orange with the intention that it would run 21 chapters, a number significant in that it was the age of legal adulthood at the time.
Like is brainwashing immoral, is it ok for the betterment of society, and what would happen if we did that in the world today. If the movie maker had previously terrified the censorship in 1961 with his version of lolita. A comparison comparisons between burgesss literary work and the film by kubrick which it inspired are, not surprisingly, numerous. A clockwork orange resucked i first published the novella a clockwork orange in 1962, which ought to be far enough in the past for it to be erased from the worlds literary memory.
Anthony burgess, author of a clockwork orange, harbored doubts about stanley kubricks screen adaptation of his 1962 novel. Those of you who have read and watched a clockwork orange. I do remember the novel wasnt as easy to consume as the movie, mainly because you can interpret spoken language more easily than understanding the lexicon employed in burgess written words. It is set in a nearfuture society that has a youth subculture of extreme violence. The differences between movie and book for a clockwork. So what do you think about a clockwork orange book vs movie. So i asked my librarian and she says that they actually did have it.
So i go home and read a couple of pages and by god it was so confusing. In this tribute from 2014, trainspotting author irvine welsh explains why burgesss a clockwork. The freedom of individuals to make choices becomes problematic when those choices undermine the safety and stability of society, and in a clockwork orange, the state is willing to protect society by taking away freedom of choice and replacing it with prescribed good behavior. Stanley kubricks adaptation of a clockwork orange opens with a closeup on alex, the hardedged protagonist and narrator of the film. Its amazing that a clockwork orange became burgesss most famous work mainly for the movie that was created for it. A clockwork orange twodisc anniversary edition bluray book. How does the film adaptation of a clockwork orange differ from the. Official thread edexcel english literature 16th may tsr movie madness. I have heard of the movie and then i found out that there was a book to it. Mar 22, 20 for a clockwork orange in particular, i prefer the movie ending better again, in theory, since i havent read the book for a couple of reasons. A clockwork orange was a novel in my parents collection of novels, which is why i turned out so well. It refuses to be erased, however, and for this the film version of the book made by stanley kubrick may be held chiefly responsible. Alex meets with dim and georgie after his release from prison, but what happened to pete during alexs incarceration is unknown.
I enjoyed it overall and it brought up some interesting points. Glenn dw will tell us something about the book then we will give you a short summary of the book, then i will give you some information about the author. Despite having much admired the directors paths of glory. One concludes with alex growing up and turning away from violence. The very first thing you want to say, is that the book is very hard to read. A clockwork orange by anthony burgess was published in. The use of nadsat can be relatively confusing for the reader, however, you slowly begin to understand the terminology while progressing through the novel. The phrase, a clockwork orange was never even mentioned, neither was the dramatic inquiry of alex, am i to be just like a clockwork orange. Themes are the fundamental and often universal ideas explored in a literary work.
It pretends to oppose the police state and forced mind control, but all it really does is celebrate the nastiness of its hero, alex. Discussion in general book discussion started by catcherintherye, feb 12, 2006. A clockwork orange, novel by anthony burgess, published in 1962. For a clockwork orange in particular, i prefer the movie ending better again, in theory, since i havent read the book for a couple of reasons. I cant remember if i read the book or watched the movie first. Pulp fiction v a clockwork orange any good book suggestions. A clockwork orange is a dystopian satirical black comedy novel by english writer anthony. The plotlines of the book and the movie are essentially the same. Burgess was a linguist and wrote the novel in a type of russian street slang, making the prose very interesting. A clockwork orange by anthony burgess was published in 1962. The novel is written in firstperson narrative of the antihero, alex, who speaks in a russianinfluenced slang called nadsat.
What are we, as human beings, willing to give up to feel safe. A clockwork orange is a dystopian satirical black comedy novel by english writer anthony burgess, published in 1962. There were even girls who wore wigs and had a dress with the names of. I have been a huge fan of anthony burgess clockwork orange, and just recently saw the movie. The korova milk bar was described to be more like a real bar where alex and the gang watched the other people within the bar. If the moviemaker had previously terrified the censorship in 1961 with his version of lolita. I love both versions of a clockwork orange book and movie. Basically, to love me is to love a clockwork orange. The film version of a clockwork orange was released in 1971. Alex delarge last name in the movie only is the protagonist villain of the 1962 book a clockwork orange originally written by the late anthony burgess, and its 1971 live action film adaptation of the same name directed by the late stanley kubrick. Alex takes home and rapes two 10yearold girls, marty and sonietta, after meeting them in a record shop. A clockwork orange is a film adaptation of anthony burgess work that has imprinted the originals alloyed language to tremendous effect. Although both versions are pretty much the same, i do think the book does some better.
One concludes with alex growing up and turning away from violence, while the second, darker version leaves out that final chapter. How does the film adaptation of a clockwork orange. After hearing so many great things about it, i must say. Instead it features nadsat, a made up language incorporating elements of cockney and russian spoken by the modern youth in the book. Book movie comparison a clockwork orange by anthony burgess and the interpretation by stanley kubrick. I consider the 1962 novella and its 1972 adaptation to be both my favorite book and favorite film. It is a dystopian novel, set in a near future english society, where. A clockwork orange is a frightening fable about good and evil, and the meaning of human freedom. While in the book nadsat was a way of masking graphic violence, the movie cannot.
May 17, 2010 i have read the book a clock work orange and i have liked it a lot. Classical conditioning in a clockwork orange psychology today. They fight they bait they attack and they even rape. In 1962, two versions of anthony burgesss novel a clockwork orange were published. The being said, the movie and book are both enjoyable. Jul 12, 2017 clockwork orange comes down to a question. Power in a clockwork orange, the government seeks to suppress individuals and individual choice in favor of the stability of the state, largely to ensure its own survival. He and his three droogs friends, sit in the darkened korova milk bar, drinking milkplus druglaced milk, and getting ready to go out and commit some ultraviolence. The differences between movie and book for a clockwork orange when two classics are nevertheless not really the same. Burgess was a linguist and wrote the novel in a type of russian. I believe that the movie just scrambled the underlying message about society that the book portrayed and instead turned it into a borderline porno. Stanley kubricks film isnt as faithful to anthony burgess novel as we first.
596 1020 82 1018 798 192 1039 846 1023 720 31 299 455 1483 490 1194 649 1354 933 278 76 354 304 713 174 336 473 956 778 844 916 610 575 672 1338 432 701